With all the anguish, sadness and bloodshed going on in Libya, we are reminded that we should never take our work too seriously. This is only advertising. However, Gadaffi's crumbling reign tells a story that is remarkably pertinent to marketers - bludgeoning people with your point of view isn't enough to sustain a happy, lasting relationship between a leader and his people.
A 'happy, lasting relationship' is the very promise of matchaffinity.com's TV ad. But for something that's trying to cultivate affinity, hope and trust, it lacks honesty. Testimonial-based advertising, although tried and tested, is over-used and easily misattributed. Watching this ad, I couldn't help thinking I was being sold a holiday to Benidorm. In addition, there was the 'try me for free this weekend' title that felt uncomfortable next to the real-life stories being told.
So, although the ad is tonally soft and authentic, it feels disingenuous, and I'm not sure there's enough here to sustain long-term interest. However, in true ecommerce ad style, with enough GRPs behind it, I'm sure it will drive an increase in direct traffic to the site. Job done?
I don't think so. A 'sentiment analysis' of online conversation shows the majority of brand comments are 'neutral'. There is a huge opportunity for matchaffinity.com to give its message depth and integrity. Why aren't the testimonials on YouTube? Or the people in the testimonials engaging in conversation with prospects to share their experiences and help them toward signing up?
Marketers today face the challenge of collapsing the space between what a brand stands for and what it does, in order to deliver positive personal experiences and peer-to-peer recommendation. Matchaffinity.com looks like it has a way to go - between its TV ad and the company's search engine, there appears to be little out there to hold the hand of a most-likely nervous and lonely heart.
Ironically, the opposite is true of the mothership campaign by match.com, which is closing the promise-fulfilment gap with its 'Going the distance' initiative. This campaign follows one couple's journey through the UK to find out what makes relationships work. Episodic in nature, the love story can be followed in more places than just the destination url - YouTube, Facebook and Twitter, for example. However, there's no positive halo for matchaffinity.com, because the campaigns appear to target different people and don't feel part of the same family.
On the upside, matchaffinity.com's promise of 'a happy, lasting relation-ship' clarifies the benefit of its 'Apple-Genius-like' recommendation service and is a strong rebuttal against major competitor eharmony.co.uk.
|Adwatch (16 March) Top 20 recalled ads|
|3||(–)||Disney Parks||Euro RSCG BETC/Carat||41|
|4||(–)||Foster's||Adam & Eve/MediaVest||40|
|6||(–)||Lotto Plus 5||
Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO/
Bartle Bogle Hegarty/
|8=||(–)||Marks & Spencer||RKCR Y&R/Walker Media||30|
Abbott Mead Vickers
|12=||(–)||Vanish Oxi Action||
Euro RSCG London/
|14=||(–)||Kellogg's Special K Clusters||Leo Burnett/Carat||24|