Adwatch (11 May) - Top 20 recall: Cushelle takes the soft approach

Cushelle opted for a small furry animal to promote its product
Cushelle opted for a small furry animal to promote its product

The toilet-tissue brand has too much pink and purple and not enough brown and yellow.

Skip to full table

Just over a year ago, Charmin toilet tissue rebranded to Cushelle, and for its brand 'icon' has chosen a koala bear. This latest ad makes no mistakes. To the accompaniment of a doowop love song, the animated koala acts out his affection for Cushelle toilet tissue. He nuzzles up to a toilet roll, wraps himself in it, even kisses it. At the end of this client-delighting demonstration of Cushelle love, a voiceover concludes: 'Koala loves Cushelle's cushiony softness.'

It feels as though it conforms 100% with the norms of the market. It has a brand name in Cushelle that seems as though chosen carefully by committee. It has a small furry animal, just like Andrex and Kittensoft. It has relaxing music that conjures up that comfortable feeling you get when you use Cushelle. It is pink and purple - just like its competitors.

It's packed full of euphemism and metaphor; it goes without saying there's no mention of toilets, or poo or wee or nether regions at all.

So the question I would ask is: is Cushelle creating a brand or a bland? Blands make no mistakes and offend no one. They whistle through research, are polite, unobtrusive and quickly forgettable. They have no teeth so require a wall of media money to cut through.

Little furry advertising properties don't have to be so bland. Look at the meerkat, the PG Tips monkey, Honey Monster.

Does the doowop music have to be quite so bland? Look at what spiky choice of music has done for brands such as John Lewis. And the bland message? No mention of toilets, poo or wee? Come on, we're grown-ups.

The toilet-tissue market reminds me a bit of the sanitary-protection market in the early 90s. In order not to cause offence, 'sanpro' ads became so euphemistic they were ridiculous.

Women bouncing up and down on trampolines and rollerskating with Dalmatians. Just plain daft.

Back then I was working on Lil-Lets. We identified it was time for simple, straight-talking ads that broke the conventions of the market and discussed the simple benefits of tampons in a grown-up way that offended no one.

The ads I wrote sent sales of Lil-Lets through the roof. I used to get fan mail saying: 'Thank you so much. At last tampon advertising written by women for women.'

If I were in the business of marketing toilet tissue now, and I wanted to create a brand that really stood out and with which people empathised, I would look to break the conventions of the market in my advertising - not replicate them.

Sometimes the biggest risk can be taking no risk at all.

Adwatch (11 May) Top 20 recall
Latest May-04 Brand Agency/TV Buyer Recall
rank       %
1 (–) Asda 

Saatchi & Saatchi/

Carat

47
2 (–) DFS  Uber/MediaCom 46
3 (–) Autoglass  Breakfast/Starcom 44
4 -1 Morrisons  DLKW Lowe/MEC 42
5 (–) Cushelle  Fallon London/Carat 38
6 (–) Sensodyne  Grey London/MediaCom 37
7= (–) Ribena  M&C Saatchi/MediaCom 35
7= -8 B&Q 

McCann Erickson/

ZenithOptimedia

35
7= (–)

Kellogg's

Coco Pops 

Leo Burnett/Carat 35
10 (6=) Wickes  MWO/MEC 34
11= (15=) Tesco 

The Red Brick Road/

Initiative

32
11= (–) Dolmio 

Proximity London/

ZenithOptimedia

32
13= -5 Aldi 

McCann Erickson

Manchester/Universal

McCann Manchester

31
13= (–) Dyson  In-house/PHD 31
15= (–) Foxy Bingo  Biscuit Agency/Concord 30
15= (–) Homebase  Leo Burnett/MindShare 30
17 (–)

Matchaffinity

.com 

Mother/Initiative 28
18 (–) Flora Cuisine  DDB UK/Mindshare 27
19= (–) Dove 

Ogilvy & Mather/

Mindshare

24
19= (–) Magnet 

CheethamBell JWT/

MediaVest Manchester

24

Discussion

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus
Brand Republic Jobs

subscribe now

Latest

Ex-Thomas Cook marketer Mike Hoban resurfaces at Morrisons
Barbour creates real-time illustrations of consumers' stories for summer campaign
Viral review: Samsung goes for Apple’s jugular but fails to connect
View from Brazil: why we didn't believe we could lose the World Cup
Heineken unveils ‘Open Your City’ drive with Metro for ‘men of the world’
Unilever continues portfolio 'reshaping' with Slim-Fast sale
Amazon to fight US authorities over in-app purchase claims
Google set to invest $100m in Europe's tech start-ups
Metcalfe's set to release quirky debut TV ad
Samsung pities the iPhone 'wall huggers'
Smirnoff campaign aims to make Formula One less elitist
Apple wins EU battle to register store layout as trademark
Marketing directors need to step outside 'marketing box' to earn seat on the board
Hottest virals: Burger King’s emotional gay pride Whopper ad, plus Apple and Guinness
Developer creates software enabling Google Glass mind-control
Kick-ass girl beats up shopping centre staff in music video
Top 10 ads of the week: Aldi's World Cup cider ad scores with consumers
Sony relives Germany's 7-1 victory against Brazil in Subbuteo Vine
Burberry credits 9% revenue hike on strong online sales and 'more targeted marketing'
Ritz returns to UK TV screens after 30-year hiatus
Mars creates chief health and wellbeing officer role
Brands make the most of Germany's dramatic victory over Brazil
Adios Justin King! Watch our video tribute as he leaves Sainsbury's after a decade
Nike calls time on 13-year Manchester United kit deal
Three TV ad banned over misleading 'free' call claims
GNM boss David Pemsel: 'The Guardian has got its mojo back'
M&S has missed a massive opportunity to put digital strategy at its heart
Google partners with the Barbican to show coders are artists
Samaritans encourages men to talk about issues with #DownNotOut campaign
Lego's partnership with Shell 'not awesome', according to Greenpeace viral