Three ads banned for misleading '3.9G' speed claims

Three: ads banned for misleading 3.9G speed claims
Three: ads banned for misleading 3.9G speed claims

Mobile operator Three has been taken to task by rival EE over implying that its '3.9G' network coverage gives mobile users close to 4G speeds, leading to the Advertising Standards Authority banning the ads.

EE took issue with the digital, press and poster campaign, which was created by agency Wieden + Kennedy, arguing that the ads were misleading.

Both a press and a poster execution were headed, "4G is nice. But our Ultrafast network is built for more".

It added, "Running at what we affectionately call 3.9G, our Ultrafast network is built to give you all-you-can-eat-data. So you won’t run out when sharing pictures of happy cheese graters. And when we roll out 4G, we’ll nudge you up without charging for the privilege. Which is nice too."

Meanwhile, Three’s website offered consumers "faster internetting without paying a premium", and said "you shouldn’t have to wait for 4G to get a great internet experience".

A page on the blog section of the site added, "What you might not know, however, is how close Ultrafast speeds can be to 4G speeds. So close in fact, that we're affectionately calling our Ultrafast network 3.9G"

EE complained that the "3.9G" label in each of the ads was misleading as it implied that the speed of Three’s broadband service was very close to that of 4G services and that the statement "our Ultrafast network is built for more" could not be substantiated.

Three-owner Hutchison defended the ads, arguing the term "3.9G" was not being used as an official technological term, but to convey how its DC-HSDPA network was "one step below" 4G technology, stressing that in the US, HSDPA is known as 4G. Three said the term was meant to communicate the superiority of its network speed over that of 3G.

While the ASA accepted that the ads did not imply that "3.9G" was an official term, it considered that the term did imply that speeds were close to 4G.

Three had provided documentary evidence to the ASA to substantiate its claims, denoting the differences between DC-HSDPA and 4G . However, the documentation was deemed too theoretical and lacking in evidence of measurable comparable speeds. Therefore the ads were ruled as misleading.

The ASA also ruled that Three had failed to substantiate the "Ultrafast" claim, which was also ruled as misleading.


Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus
Brand Republic Jobs

subscribe now


Ex-Thomas Cook marketer Mike Hoban resurfaces at Morrisons
Barbour creates real-time illustrations of consumers' stories for summer campaign
Viral review: Samsung goes for Apple’s jugular but fails to connect
View from Brazil: why we didn't believe we could lose the World Cup
Heineken unveils ‘Open Your City’ drive with Metro for ‘men of the world’
Unilever continues portfolio 'reshaping' with Slim-Fast sale
Amazon to fight US authorities over in-app purchase claims
Google set to invest $100m in Europe's tech start-ups
Metcalfe's set to release quirky debut TV ad
Samsung pities the iPhone 'wall huggers'
Smirnoff campaign aims to make Formula One less elitist
Apple wins EU battle to register store layout as trademark
Marketing directors need to step outside 'marketing box' to earn seat on the board
Hottest virals: Burger King’s emotional gay pride Whopper ad, plus Apple and Guinness
Developer creates software enabling Google Glass mind-control
Kick-ass girl beats up shopping centre staff in music video
Top 10 ads of the week: Aldi's World Cup cider ad scores with consumers
Sony relives Germany's 7-1 victory against Brazil in Subbuteo Vine
Burberry credits 9% revenue hike on strong online sales and 'more targeted marketing'
Ritz returns to UK TV screens after 30-year hiatus
Mars creates chief health and wellbeing officer role
Brands make the most of Germany's dramatic victory over Brazil
Adios Justin King! Watch our video tribute as he leaves Sainsbury's after a decade
Nike calls time on 13-year Manchester United kit deal
Three TV ad banned over misleading 'free' call claims
GNM boss David Pemsel: 'The Guardian has got its mojo back'
M&S has missed a massive opportunity to put digital strategy at its heart
Google partners with the Barbican to show coders are artists
Samaritans encourages men to talk about issues with #DownNotOut campaign
Lego's partnership with Shell 'not awesome', according to Greenpeace viral